Distinctions

Spring 2015

Self-Deception, Part two

“…To believe that he or she is the owner of the truth, or the legitimate defender of some principle… he or she immediately becomes blind to his or her circumstances and enters into the closed alley of fanaticism.”—Humberto Maturana

Featured Article • Self-Deception, Part two

Self-Deception, Part two

by James Flaherty

None of us is free from self-deception. The deepest self-deception, as I said in the last issue of Distinctions, is that I am not fooling myself—that I have not been taken in by my explanations/justifications/great insights. But wise people know better. The great Chilean biologist Maturana points out that a most egregious deception is when we take ourselves as the ones holding the truth and exclude others; we disdain questioning ourselves and instead wall ourselves off from influence.

Maturana also reminds us that what we hold as true arises at a unique time and place, within a particular culture of people sharing expectations, practices and language. (By the way—people in ancient times were not less intelligent; they simply did not have the accrued knowledge of subsequent centuries, including scientific observational paraphernalia.) We all know the countless examples of “the true” being overturned by further evidence or new discovery.

Yet we hold on and readily become adamant, defensive, or even hostile. American political campaigns are, for the most part, essentially this holding on played out. And U.S. so-called “news networks” are this pattern greatly amplified.

But my point here is how do I attach myself to “the true” in a defended way— including the modern, laid-back defense of “whatever,” or seeming to be open when, in our actions, we are not.

What truths are you holding onto? What self-deception is involved?

As my friend Raz Ingrasci says, “The truth believed is a lie.” That’s because it’s no longer alive, but exists as a concept that may or may not ever be relevant again (for example, I’m good at puzzles, or with people, or in time management, and so on).

Or because we no longer feel it—it’s just that we’ve been saying it for so long and haven’t checked back in with ourselves for a while—we might say, “of course I love my partner.” But really? And now?

This form of self-deception is really important because it remains so buried and at the same time fundamental to our identity. Consequently it’s key to coaching. Let’s be sure we check in to what our client says as “true” about her/him and not join in the self-deception by believing that people know themselves quite well. That’s really the point of these 2 articles: we don’t, and don’t know that.

Maybe, though, by now you are willing to entertain the notion that you, like me, engage in self-deception all the time. Then what?

First of all we can relax our holding onto our notions, beliefs, conclusions, truths about ourselves. That alone will make our life more spacious, leave us more open to learning and more affected by what we encounter. Maybe I do like black licorice even though I’ve been saying I don’t. Of course there are much more consequential examples. Is this still my calling? Am I ready to listen to people I’ve been dismissing?

Second, we can begin to look for ways we are deceiving ourselves. Given this article, a good place to begin is what we are super certain about, what we become fanatical about, what we adamantly, unmercifully advocate for.

What are these for you?

Third, we can examine whom we surround ourselves with:

  • Only people who always agree? How can that foster self-deception?
  • Only people that we keep at a distance? How can they show us the ways we are fooling ourselves?
  • Only people that we feel better than, smarter than, have more power than? How will we hear and be affected by what they tell us?

Whom do you listen to? Whom do you shut out? How does that play into ways you might be deceiving yourself? Whom could you bring in to help keep you awake?

And of course one of our central coaching questions: what practices do you see you can take up to lessen self-deception?

My list includes:

  • ongoing spiritual practice with a clear-seeing, clear-speaking teacher
  • learning new things that deeply challenge my set-in notions of what I can do and can’t
  • working with a trusted, competent therapist
  • having deep, exploratory conversations with courageous intimates
  • reading books that argue against what I think is true

And what’s your list?

More on this topic in the practice of the quarter, the poems that follow, and the book review, which this time is especially germane.

Please take care of yourself.

Love,

Practice • Self-Deception

Focus: Self-Deception

Please take up this practice for 30 to 45 days.

Please stop 2 or 3 times each day and ask yourself the following questions. Please write down brief notes so that you can begin to notice patterns.

During this period of time:

  • In which specific ways did I question that which I hold to be unquestionably true, without self-criticism and without self-doubt?
  • How much challenge did I welcome to my notions of myself, reality, others? What effect did that have on me?
  • How did I specifically join in the views, actions, conclusions of others with little or no questioning?
  • How will I take what I’ve learned in this exercise into my life so that I lessen my self-deception?

Poetry & Reading

Poems of the Quarter

Poems by Emily Dickinson

Emily Dickinson

At the center of Indifference I feel my own freedom … the Liberty in wavering. Compression of possibility tensing to spring. Might and might … mystic illumination of analogies … instinctive human supposition that any word may mean its opposite. Occult tendency of opposites to attract and merge. Hesitation of us all, one fire-baptized soul was singing.

—Susan Howe, from My Emily Dickinson

In many and reportless places
We feel a Joy –
Reportless, also, but sincere as Nature
Or Deity –

It comes, without a consternation –
Dissolves – the same –
But leaves a sumptuous Destitution –
Without a Name –

Profane it by a search – we cannot
It has no home –
Nor we who having once inhaled it –
Thereafter roam.

(1382)

That sacred Closet when you sweep –
Entitled “Memory” –
Select a reverential Broom –
And do it silently.

‘Twill be a Labor of surprise –
Besides Identity
Of other Interlocutors
A probability –

August the Dust of that Domain
Unchallenged – let it lie –
You cannot supersede itself
But it can silence you –

(1273)

In lands I never saw – they say
Immortal Alps look down –
Whose Bonnets touch the firmament –
Whose Sandals touch the town –

Meek at whose everlasting feet
A Myriad Daisy play –
Which, Sir, are you and which am I
Upon an August day?

(124)

My Life had stood – a Loaded Gun –
In Corners – till a Day
The Owner passed – identified –
And carried Me away –

And now We roam in Sovereign Woods –
And now We hunt the Doe –
And every time I speak for Him –
The Mountains straight reply –

And do I smile, such cordial light
Upon the Valley glow –
It is as a Vesuvian face
Had let it’s pleasure through –

And when at Night – Our good Day done –
I guard My Master’s Head –
‘Tis better than the Eider-Duck’s
Deep Pillow – to have shared –

To foe of His – I’m deadly foe –
None stir the second time –
On whom I lay a Yellow Eye –
Or an emphatic Thumb –

Though I than He – may longer live
He longer must – than I –
For I have but the power to kill,
Without – the power to die –

(754)

Book of the Quarter

The Reality of Being: The Fourth Way of Gurdjieff

Jeanne De Salzmann
Shambala, 2011
Paperback, 336 pages

New to me, but nonetheless certainly one of the top 25 most important books I’ve read in terms of coaching and my own development.

Gurdjieff (1866-1949), as you may know, traveled throughout the Middle East and Western Asia and uncovered ancient wisdom that he coalesced into teaching that he called “the fourth way.” He himself made it difficult to learn this method by writing dense, obscure books and making entry to his hidden school difficult.

Authors who took up writing about the fourth way—most prominently Ouspensky and Bennett, but also Nicoll and others—did a somewhat better job in making the teaching accessible.

But never with so much amazing heart and clarity as Jeanne De Salzmann. Each of her sentences is short, clear and profound. Paragraphs are worth studying for a week, and she writes with such enticing truth telling that we are drawn to do that.

She lays out our human condition—our being asleep and not knowing it, our self-indulgent self-importance, our ways of living that keep us confused with open eyed honesty—and yet never with despair, cynicism or resignation.

In other words, she’s a genuine teacher: someone who knows our entrenched difficulty and yet shows us a realistic, grounded way through.

Please get this book and read pages 24 and 25 and let her get to you. Her depiction, evocation of self-observation is like nothing I’ve ever encountered, and it has the power to forever shift who we take ourselves to be, who others are for us, and how we function in the world. Reading it is like doing a three-month retreat where the entire world becomes transparent, beautiful, loving and inseparable from us.

Reading this book is like discovering Emily Dickinson or Virginia Woolf—a wondrous head scratching encounter—how could someone know this? How is she saying it in a way that is changing everything for me?

The best of the best.

– James Flaherty

News & Updates

Helping Coaches Thrive: NVW Reinvents Itself as a Multi-Year Institution

It is probably not news to anyone reading this that coaching has become a widely recognized profession. With more and more coaches being “born” every day, the work is spreading exponentially into large corporations, nonprofits, government agencies, and other spheres of influence. The need for this service in the world can no longer be denied. How are we prepared to meet it?

Responding to the Need for Continuous Unfolding

We know the coach’s own development is vital for her to work effectively. The bottomless well of unconscious patterns, biases and judgments that exist in all of us threatens to cloud our work, which all of us have no doubt seen ourselves. We so easily become habituated and don’t notice it. We can swirl around at our level of development and stay away from facing the difficult, confusing or complex.

It’s essential that we keep unfolding, engaging others and the world at deeper levels. And we know that doing this on our own is nearly impossible. Being in a community of development, being surrounded by attuned, intelligent support, and learning new competencies make our developmental journey much more possible, more dynamic and tremendously more fun.

We also have to keep our skills as current as our growth and discovery. A good coach training program doesn’t simply supply a pervasive, “take-everywhere” toolkit to use in all situations. The world is changing; our clients are developing; we ourselves are waking up new every day. We need to be constantly expanding our range of resources to engage our work in fresh and fulfilling ways.

Though New Ventures West has always been dedicated to the lifelong learning and development of the coach, what has not been available until now is a rigorous, long-term course of study that supports, in an ongoing way, the journey that is begun in the PCC.

Graduate Programs: A Path Towards Mastery
Towards Mastery is a suite of programs for New Ventures West graduates. Each rigorous 9-month course is intended to move coaches further into their vocation by engendering greater skill in coaching, power in speaking, and depth of development. We’ll go further into understanding and using the Ten Ways; develop our artistry with design and assessments; discover what it really takes to take this work into a thriving business practice.

If you have been through the PCC, you know: certification is the start of ever-deepening self-exploration, learning, and attunement. Much like a university undergraduate, the option now exists to obtain a kind of master’s degree (or several!) by moving ahead with a focused study in an area of particular interest to you.

And this all happens, of course, in the catalytic environment of New Ventures West. The courses provide a powerful incubator in which this ongoing growth can occur and will involve as much experience and personal development as the PCC—perhaps even more robustly. As James says,

“We’ve discovered that bringing together post-PCC graduates almost instantly generates a very strong, safe, supportive container in which everyone involved begins to unfold, become more competent, and relax into themselves at an unexpectedly accelerated rate.”

On their own, we already see graduates taking up spiritual paths, courses of study, and practices that can support them and all those with whom they interact and serve. The Towards Mastery programs will augment and magnify these individual efforts.

What Hasn’t Changed

Throughout our almost 30 years as a coach training institution, our recognition of this need has remained consistent, as evidenced by our menu of offerings for graduates of the PCC as well as coaches of other backgrounds. Weekend workshops, teleclasses, and free quarterly seminars provide opportunities for graduates to touch back into the community and come away with something new for themselves and their clients.

These classes are still available – whether it’s deepening your understanding of the Enneagram, participating in the Book Study Group, slaying your inner critic once and for all, or spending a Saturday with us at a Roundtable, we welcome graduates to continue to engage with us in these shorter-term ways.

Evolving With the Field

And we acknowledge that stepping into the vocation of coaching brings with it a new set of weighty demands, especially given our current world situation. As an institution, it is our calling to not only prepare but also support our graduates—in a way that is robust and sustainable—so that they can thrive in a profession that is becoming ever more crucial in our complex world.

Read more about the new programs here.

Graduate News

From the graduate director

Dear Graduates,

It’s blustery this time of year in our town—the bushes rustle and trees sway about. The constancy of the wind reminds me of two things. First, how life sometimes feels as though it’s blowing us about; from one task, event, meeting, to the next. The other aspect of it, and perhaps more important, is its fleeting nature. As the wind comes and goes, so do our lives—able to affect and savor what is around us for a short while and then gone. In either case remember to feel the wind upon you and continually, in ever deepening contact, remember that you are the breeze upon others.

Thank you for what you bring to our community. I look forward to supporting you in your ongoing development—be sure to read about our new Towards Mastery programs.

Love,

Adam Klein

PS. If you haven’t already, please join the NVW Alumni Facebook Group by sending a request to join.

Congratulations and welcome to our new graduates!

Ev Abendanon, Saxonwold, South Africa
Dennis Adsit, Redwood City, CA, USA
Ginna Anderson, Santa Monica, CA, USA
Monica Anderson, San Carlos, CA, USA
April Austin, Cary, NC, USA
Sahar Azarabadi, San Francisco, CA, USA
Magda Barcelo, Boulder, CO, USA
Marco Bas, Portland, OR, USA
Alan Berusch, San Francisco, CA, USA
Lindsy Bolus, Claremont, South Africa
Juanita Booth, Green Point, South Africa
Stephanie Breslin, El Granada, CA, USA
Trish Calvani, Mountville, PA, USA
Bobbie Carter, Alexandria, VA, USA
Charmaine Cassidy, Paulshof, South Africa
Yvette Castanon, Morgan Hill, CA, USA
Yuwen Chu, San Francisco, CA, USA
Gwynne Corrigan, Cupertino, CA, USA

Sharon Cuff, Johannesburg, South Africa
Bev Doran, Huntington, CT, USA
Helen During, Rondebosch, South Africa
Andrea Flynn, Mill Valley, CA, USA
Julia Fourie, Durbanville, South Africa
Stacy Gardner, Benicia, CA, USA
Ina Gjikondi, Washington, DC, USA
Joanne Gordon, Los Gatos, CA, USA
Karl Gostner, Cape Town, South Africa
Shannon Haddaway, Fort Worth, TX, USA
Adenike Harris, Los Angeles, CA, USA
Natasha Hartman, Pleasant Hill, CA, USA
Megan Hilburn, Bryanston, South Africa
Angela Hoffman, Colorado Springs, CO, USA
Kore Koubourlis, Kirkland, WA, USA
Dale Lautenbach, Alexandria, VA, USA
Trish Lees, Rivonia, South Africa
Hope Lukoto, Meadowlands, South Africa

David Marvin, Durango, CO, USA
Sifiso Mbuyisa, Cape Town, South Africa
Dorothy Ndletyana, Wendywood, South Africa
Andile Ngcaba, Bryanston, South Africa
Janet Purcell van Graan, Claremont, South Africa
Rashida Sader, Rondebosch, South Africa
Bridget Sellick, Claremont, South Africa
Eveline Shum, Amsterdam, Netherlands
Jon Shuster, Oakland, CA, USA
Veronica Skelton, Corte Madera, CA, USA
Galina Szakacs, Nashua, NH, USA
Wilna Van Zyl, Lyttelton, South Africa
Masha Vorobyova-Sweitzer, Phoenix, AZ, USA
Lauren Voges, Windhoek, South Africa
Milly Williams, Sunninghill, South Africa
Nikki Wohlman, Fresnaye, South Africa
Philip York, Deerfield, IL, USA

PCC “X” celebrates their graduation in Washington DC last month. Congratulations, friends!

$0.00 (0 items)
0

No products in the cart.